Back to Blog

Career

Impact

How to Hire an SDR: A Step-by-Step Guide

How to Hire an SDR: A Step-by-Step Guide

two ladies in an office in suit going over files

A sales development representative, usually called an SDR, starts conversations with potential customers and books meetings for a more senior salesperson. For many companies, it's the first sales hire after the founders, and one of the hardest to get right.

The role looks simple from the outside. It isn't. The person needs to handle a lot of rejection, stay organized, learn fast, and keep a steady pace for months. Hiring on resume alone, or on a good first impression, often misses the traits that matter.

This guide walks through ten steps, from deciding whether to hire one at all to measuring how it's going. It's written for founders, sales leaders, and hiring managers. It's general guidance, not legal advice, and it includes no pay figures, because pay varies too much by market and company.


A Quick Note on Titles

Companies don't agree on these titles. At many companies, SDR and BDR (business development representative) mean the same job. At others, one focuses on inbound leads and the other on outbound outreach, though which is which differs. Whatever you call the role, describe the tasks in your posting. Our guide to sales job titles explained covers the differences.


Step One: Decide Whether You're Ready

An SDR works best when a few things are already in place. Check these before you hire.

A clear offer. You can explain what you sell and who it's for in a few sentences.

A defined target customer. You know who the SDR should contact, and why.

Someone to take the meetings. A founder or account executive who will follow up on every meeting the SDR books.

A way to track the work. A simple system for logging outreach, meetings, and results.

Time to coach. Someone who will review calls and give feedback every week.

If several of these are missing, hiring an SDR may be early. A new hire can't make up for an unclear offer, and the first few months will be spent guessing.


Step Two: Define the Outcomes

Before you write anything, decide what success looks like. Write down three to five outcomes for the first six months, in plain words.

For example, the outcomes might be starting conversations with a defined list of target accounts, booking qualified meetings for the account executive, and keeping accurate records. Define what "qualified" means, because it's the most common source of disagreement between SDRs and the people taking their meetings.

Also decide whether the work is mostly outbound, mostly inbound, or a mix. Outbound means reaching out to people who haven't asked to hear from you. Inbound means responding to people who have. The traits you need differ, and candidates will want to know. Our guide to sales roles without cold calling explains the difference from the candidate's side.


Step Three: Decide Who You're Looking For

Resist the urge to hire a copy of your last successful person. Choose four to six traits that lead to the outcomes you wrote down, and describe each one in terms of what you can observe.

Common choices for this role include coachability, resilience, drive, communication, curiosity, reliability, and organization. Coachability means the person takes feedback and changes what they do. Resilience means they describe setbacks honestly and show what they did next.

Experience helps, but it isn't required for most entry-level SDR roles. Many strong candidates come from customer-facing jobs, hospitality, retail, coaching, or sport. Our guide to building a hiring scorecard shows how to turn the traits into ratings and questions.


Step Four: Write the Posting

A good posting attracts the right people and discourages the wrong ones. Describe the day to day. Say what the role measures, what training you provide, and where the role can lead.

Be clear about how pay works. State the base and the variable parts plainly, and explain any ramp period. People who can't accept the structure will skip a posting that states it, which saves everyone time. Our guide to writing job postings that attract former athletes covers more.


Step Five: Find Candidates

Use more than one channel. Common ones include job boards, referrals from your team and network, university career offices, communities in your industry, and networks of former athletes. A verified athlete network gives you candidates whose athletic background has already been confirmed.

Decide in advance how many applications you can handle well. If a posting draws more than you expected, our guide to handling a flood of applicants for one sales role covers how to sort them fairly.


Step Six: Screen

Start with the resume, but don't stop there. Read for results, responsibility that grew over time, and signs of coachability. Don't filter out someone for a single missing item. Our guide to what recruiters get wrong about athlete resumes covers how to read non-traditional backgrounds.

Then add a short screening step. Two or three questions, answered in writing or on a brief call, tell you more than the resume does. Here are examples you can adapt.

"Tell me about a time you changed your approach after feedback. What did you change, and what happened?"

"What's a goal you set for yourself, and how did you track it?"

"Tell me about a time you were told no. What did you do next?"

Keep the first call short and consistent. Ask every candidate the same questions, and take notes on what they actually said.


Step Seven: Test the Skills

A short, fair exercise shows you how someone works. The two most common are a role-play call and a short outreach exercise.

Role-play. Give the candidate a simple scenario a day ahead, such as a first call to a person in your target customer group. Play the prospect yourself, and keep it to about fifteen minutes. You're not looking for a perfect call. You're looking at how they prepare, how they listen, and how they respond when you push back. Then give them one piece of feedback and see what they do with it.

Written outreach. Ask the candidate to write a short message to a sample prospect. Keep it brief and relevant. If a task takes more than an hour or so, consider paying for it.

Avoid trick questions and tests that don't look like the job. They measure how well someone handles tests.


Step Eight: Interview and Compare

Use a structured interview, with the same questions for every candidate, tied to your traits. Include the person who will manage the SDR and, where you can, the account executive who will take their meetings.

Fill in your scorecard separately before you discuss. Then compare the evidence behind each rating. Reference checks can help too. Ask former managers and coaches for examples tied to the same traits, and treat one reference as one data point.


Step Nine: Make the Offer

Call first, explain the main terms, and answer questions. Then send the written offer soon after. Be honest about the realities of the job, including the rejection, the targets, and how the variable pay works.

Put the base in the letter and the commission details in a written plan, and give the candidate the plan before they accept. Our guide to writing a job offer letter covers the structure and what to get a lawyer to review.


Step Ten: Onboard and Ramp

The first months decide a lot. Plan them before the person starts.

Weeks one and two. Product and customer training. Listen to recorded calls. Shadow someone experienced.

Weeks three and four. Start live outreach with close support. Use scripts as a starting point, and encourage the person to make them their own.

The following months. Raise the targets in steps as the person improves. Review calls every week, give direct feedback, and set clear expectations for each stage.

Say plainly how long the ramp period is, and what is expected during it. Our guides to onboarding a former athlete into a corporate role and to designing sales incentives for competitive hires cover this in more detail.


Measure and Adjust

Track two kinds of numbers. Early signs include activity, such as calls, emails, and messages, and the share of conversations that turn into meetings. Later results include qualified meetings, the pipeline they create, and the deals that follow.

Don't judge too early on results alone. Look at the whole picture, and ask whether the process, the targets, and the coaching are working before you decide a person isn't. After your first few hires, review what the best performers had in common, and update your scorecard.


Mistakes to Avoid

Hiring too early. Without a clear offer and someone to take meetings, a new hire has little to work with.

A vague definition of qualified. It leads to arguments about meeting quality.

Hiring on experience alone. Traits like coachability and resilience matter more than the last title.

Skipping the ramp plan. A new person with no plan guesses at what's expected.

Measuring only activity. Calls and emails matter, but quality and results matter too.

Too little coaching. Weekly feedback usually does more than any script.

No path forward. People stay longer when they can see what comes next.

Vague pay. State the structure plainly, and put commission in a written plan.


A Sample Six-Week Hiring Timeline

Here's an example. Adjust it to your team.

Week one. Decide the outcomes and the traits. Build your scorecard.

Week two. Write the posting and start sourcing.

Week three. Screen applications and hold first calls.

Week four. Run role-plays and interviews.

Week five. Check references, compare scorecards, and make the offer.

Week six. Handle acceptance, prepare the ramp plan, and tell other finalists kindly.


Where Free Agent Fits

Former athletes can make strong SDRs, but a sports background is a place to look for evidence of the traits above, not a shortcut around evaluating them. Free Agent is a private network of verified current and former athletes, so you can start with candidates whose athletic background has already been confirmed, and use your scorecard on the rest. If you're hiring, Free Agent is where to start.

Get started at gofreeagent.com


FAQs About Hiring an SDR

What does an SDR do?

A sales development representative starts conversations with potential customers and books meetings for a more senior salesperson, such as an account executive. The work usually includes outreach by phone, email, or social messages, and keeping records of the results.

When should a startup hire its first SDR?

When it has a clear offer, a defined target customer, someone to take the meetings the SDR books, and a way to track the work. Without those, a new hire has little to build on.

What should you look for in an SDR?

Traits that lead to results, such as coachability, resilience, drive, communication, curiosity, reliability, and organization. Experience helps but isn't required for most entry-level roles, and strong candidates come from many backgrounds.

How do you interview an SDR?

Use a structured interview with the same questions for every candidate, tied to the traits you chose. Add a short role-play and a brief writing exercise, and score each candidate on a scorecard before you discuss.

How long does it take to ramp a new SDR?

It varies by company and by how complex your product is. Plan a ramp period in advance, say how long it is and what is expected during it, and raise targets in steps.

How much should I pay an SDR?

Pay varies by market and company. Look at current postings for similar roles near you, state the base and variable pay plainly, and put commission in a written plan.